Starbucks bets you pay for the chair. Its U.S. visits rose 3.4%

Starbucks spent years turning cafes into pickup counters. Under Brian Niccol it is paying to put the chairs back, and U.S. visits are growing again. Here is the math behind the seat.

By The Providers DeskPublished First told as a video on Oct 21, 20265 min read

Three frames from our video: a glowing sketch of a cafe labeled third place, a phone order and a drive-thru, a green armchair
Frames from our video
U.S. sales FY26
+6.5%1
U.S. visits FY26
+3.4%1
Visits Q4 FY24
-10%5
Per store redo
~$150,0009
In this story
  1. Where the “third place” came from
  2. How the app emptied the chairs
  3. What “Back to Starbucks” changed
  4. The numbers so far
  5. What the chair is worth

Starbucks is betting that what customers really pay for is a place to sit. After two years of falling visits, it has brought back ceramic mugs, softer chairs and power outlets, and in fiscal 2026 its U.S. comparable store sales rose 6.5%, with the number of transactions up 3.4%.13 Chief executive Brian Niccol calls the goal “reclaiming the third place.”2

That is a reversal. In the years before Niccol arrived, Starbucks pushed customers toward the app and the drive-thru, and by 2024 those orders made up more than 70% of sales at its U.S. company-operated stores.6 The question behind the turnaround is simple: if a coffee to go can be bought anywhere, what makes a latte worth its price?

Watch · 0:54Video pageTranscript
Read the video transcript

You think you pay Starbucks for the coffee. You don't. You pay for the chair.

Its new boss, Brian Niccol, brought back ceramic mugs, comfy chairs and handwritten names. Sales jumped 7.9%.

Sociologist Ray Oldenburg called it the third place. Not home, not work. In between.

Howard Schultz built Starbucks on it. The coffee got you in. The seat made you stay.

Then came the app and the drive-thru: over 70% of sales by 2024. Coffee to go, you can get anywhere.

Now Niccol is buying the seat back: new chairs and power outlets in 1,000 stores. Visits are up 4.2%.

So if you buy the coffee, take the seat. And if you sell anything, know what people really pay you for.

Where the “third place” came from

The phrase belongs to the sociologist Ray Oldenburg. His 1989 book The Great Good Place described informal gathering spots, a third place after home and work, and pointed to the coffeehouse as somewhere strangers can spend time together.7 Howard Behar, a Starbucks executive who joined the company in 1989, has traced the company’s idea of the third place back to that book.7

Howard Schultz, Starbucks’ longtime leader, positioned its cafes as that third place.6 He once wrote that “providing the world with a warm and welcoming third place may just be our most important role and responsibility.”7 The drink got you through the door; the room gave you a reason to stay.

How the app emptied the chairs

Mobile ordering and drive-thru lanes made buying faster, and customers used them heavily. CNN reported in July 2024 that app and drive-thru orders made up more than 70% of sales at the roughly 9,500 company-operated U.S. stores, and that the chain had built pickup-only stores without seating.6

The trouble showed up in the visit counts. In the quarter to September 2024, U.S. comparable transactions (the number of orders at stores open at least a year) fell 10%. A 4% rise in the average ticket kept the sales decline to 6%.5 Over the following fiscal year, U.S. transactions fell another 4%.5

Starbucks replaced chief executive Laxman Narasimhan in August 2024, after two straight quarters of falling same-store sales. Niccol, who had run Chipotle, took over on September 9.10

Read also McDonald's says prices rose 40% in 5 years. Then it cut deals; visits fell

What “Back to Starbucks” changed

Niccol’s plan, branded “Back to Starbucks,” started with small, visible things. From January 27, 2025, drinks for customers who stay were served in ceramic mugs, condiment bars came back, and baristas went back to writing names on cups with Sharpies.8 At the same time, Starbucks added a code of conduct: customers now have to buy something to hang out or use the restroom.8 A third place, in other words, but one for paying customers.

The bigger spending came with the stores themselves. The makeovers bring softer and more varied seating, warmer lighting, couches and more power outlets spread around the room instead of only along the walls. Restaurant Dive reported in May 2026 that the chain planned to finish about 1,000 of them in 2026, out of about 11,000 company-operated stores in North America, at about $150,000 per location.9 By that arithmetic, the 2026 program alone costs about $150 million.

At one renovated Chicago store, in-store customers had been about 10% of sales, and the manager said the share of in-store traffic had roughly doubled after the work.9 That is one store’s account, not chain-wide data, but it shows what the money is meant to buy.

The plan also cut. In the quarter to September 2025, Starbucks closed 627 stores under a restructuring plan, more than 90% of them in North America.5 It closed about 250 more North American company-operated stores in September 2026 that, in its words, “do not deliver the coffeehouse experience and financial performance expected of the brand.”1

The numbers so far

The turn showed up in the first quarter of fiscal 2026, the three months to December 2025. U.S. comparable transactions rose 3%, the first increase in eight quarters.3 A year earlier, the same measure had been down 8%.3 “Our Q1 results demonstrate our ‘Back to Starbucks’ strategy is working and we believe we’re ahead of schedule,” Niccol said at the time.3

Fig. 1U.S. comparable transactions at Starbucks, change from a year earlier
-10%
Jul–Sep 2024, before Niccol's plan
-1%
Jul–Sep 2025, one year in
+4.3%
Jan–Mar 2026, the strongest quarter of fiscal 2026

Sources: [3], [4], [5]

Growth then picked up. U.S. comparable store sales rose 7.1% in the second quarter and 7.9% in the third, when transactions rose 4.2%: the “visits up 4.2%” in our video.24 Niccol called the second quarter “the turn in our turnaround.”4

Fig. 2Starbucks U.S. comparable store sales growth by quarter, fiscal 2026
Show the data
ItemValue
Q1 (Oct–Dec 2025)+4.0%
Q2 (Jan–Mar 2026)+7.1%
Q3 (Apr–Jun 2026)+7.9%
Q4 (Jul–Sep 2026)+7.7%

Sources: [1], [2], [3], [4]

The latest quarter is less tidy. U.S. sales still rose 7.7% in the three months to September 2026, but transactions grew only 2.4% while the average ticket, what each customer spends per visit, rose 5.2%.1 For the full year, U.S. growth was split almost evenly: transactions up 3.4%, ticket up 3.0%.1

Timeline

  1. 1989

    Ray Oldenburg's book The Great Good Place describes the 'third place' between home and work.7

  2. Jul 2024

    CNN reports that app and drive-thru orders are more than 70% of sales at U.S. company-operated stores.6

  3. Sep 9, 2024

    Brian Niccol takes over as chief executive, replacing Laxman Narasimhan.10

  4. Jan 27, 2025

    Ceramic mugs, condiment bars and handwritten names return; staying or using restrooms now requires a purchase.8

  5. Jan 2026

    U.S. comparable transactions grow for the first time in eight quarters.3

  6. May 2026

    About 1,000 store makeovers are planned for 2026, at about $150,000 each.9

  7. Oct 29, 2026

    Fiscal 2026 closes with U.S. comparable store sales up 6.5%.1

Starbucks now describes the plan differently. “Back to Starbucks started as our turnaround plan. Now, it’s our growth plan,” Niccol said on October 29.1 For fiscal 2027, the company expects North America comparable sales growth of about 4%.1

The seats have not wrecked the margins, at least not yet. In the third quarter, Starbucks said “labor investments largely in support of ‘Back to Starbucks’” weighed on results, yet its non-GAAP operating margin (profit from operations before one-off items, as a share of sales) still rose 4.3 percentage points to 14.4%.2 For the full fiscal year, that margin was 11.9% on net revenue of $37.9 billion, up 2%.1

The scale is worth keeping in mind. Starbucks ended fiscal 2026 with 41,607 coffeehouses worldwide, 16,781 of them in the U.S.1 Revenue in the last quarter fell 4% to $9.1 billion, mainly because Starbucks sold control of its China stores, which now run as a licensed joint venture.1 At about 1,000 makeovers a year, redoing all of the roughly 11,000 company-operated stores in North America would take about a decade.9

What the chair is worth

Starbucks is not the only chain whose prices are really about something other than the product; we collect these cases on our price-tag pages. McDonald’s ran into the opposite problem, where app deals taught customers what a burger should cost, as we explain in why McDonald’s pulled back its app deals. And a retailer that dropped its constant sales for everyday prices saw its yearly sales fall by about $4 billion, in the J.C. Penney pricing story.

How this story was made: researched and drafted with AI tools from the sources listed below, then checked against those sources claim by claim before publication. The Providers is responsible for everything published here. How we use AI · Report an error.

Sources

Every number and claim above links to one of these. Primary sources are documents from the people or institutions involved.

  1. 1StarbucksPrimaryStarbucks Reports Q4 and Full Fiscal Year 2026 ResultsOct 29, 2026
  2. 2Starbucks / SECPrimaryQ3 fiscal 2026 earnings release (Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1)Jul 29, 2026
  3. 3Starbucks / SECPrimaryQ1 fiscal 2026 earnings release (Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1)Jan 28, 2026
  4. 4Starbucks / SECPrimaryQ2 fiscal 2026 earnings release (Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1)Apr 28, 2026
  5. 5Starbucks / SECPrimaryQ4 and full fiscal year 2025 earnings release (Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1)Oct 29, 2025
  6. 6CNN (via KVIA)Starbucks wanted to be the 'third place.' Now it's speeding you out the doorJul 19, 2024
  7. 7CNN (via WRAL)Why Starbucks needs you to feel at homeJun 26, 2018
  8. 8CNN (via KSL.com)Changes at Starbucks roll out MondayJan 27, 2025
  9. 9Restaurant DiveInside Starbucks' atmospheric and experiential renovationsMay 21, 2026
  10. 10Nation's Restaurant NewsChipotle's Brian Niccol named Starbucks CEO, replacing Laxman NarasimhanAug 13, 2024

Follow the cases

A new case every day, as a 90-second video.

Know a story we should open? Suggest a case.

More cases like this